For What It's Worth
In my opinion OBD II is a typical Government program gone bad. There are too many potential chances for fault codes
for no apparemt reason. Between ping, echo, call & response signaling in a OBD II system there are 4 chances for a fault.
In fact it's so whacky that FoMoCo runs their diagnostic readouts thru' Oasis at Dearborn or wherever so Dealers can tap
into FoMoCo's data base to figure out what to do with driveability issues.
Also there's a pending code thing when less than all 4 OBD II signals pass & other(s) fail but no give a DTC with reason for a failure.
The Pending Code It just floats around in the system RAM until something happens, or it hangs in for 47 starts then self deletes.
I agree 96 & up engine is more sophisticated & advanced, but I know the OBD II Diagnostics hinder best performance from it.
I've been thinking about what would happen if OBD I was retrofitted to a OBD II type engine & a chip was burned for desired
performance parameters for the installation that was built in the conversion to another vehicle. ? ? ?
I have & use an OBD II scanner frequently and without the benefit of the Oasis connection FoMoCo dealers have, I am forced
to do a lot of extra Diag work. For Example a lean burn on bank 1 with an excessive EGR flow can be caused by something as stupid
as a broken clip holding an injector harness plug on an injector in right or #1 bank of a V configured engine.
I also work on, have & run OBD I FoMoCo systems. I find OBD I is less complicated & they have fewer sensors & circuits & codes to deal with.
It is easier to get my Diag's right in an OBD I system than in OBD II. It also allows me to get the vehicle out the door both faster I cheaper for the
owners, and I get way fewer complaints & comebacks with OBD I.
Of course this is just my opinion. It is based on what I've done on & with these 2 systems. Once I learned the OBD I system and located a good code reference source, I've Never had to take an OBD I into a FoMoCo Dealer to have a scan translated. BUT what's worse, I've taken a OBD II systems in, paid the BIG $$$$$ prices & still not resolved issues we were having.
I'm sure people will claim they shoe-horn OBD II run powerplants in retro fit applications all the time and have absolutely no Problems at all ever. I say God Bless them & carry on, but I am not one of them myself.
I've enough grief trying to get OEM Stock OBD II systems to perform & diagnose correctly in the vehicles they came in,
Oh & Yeah,
And Thanks Uncle Sam. . . . .
FBp 