Page 1 of 1
Why I don't like closed knuckle axles-Ice, this is for you!
Posted: February 24, 2007, 5:32 pm
by Comet
The rather thin walls of the u-joint housing (roughly half as thin as an open knuckle design) makes things like this an all too common occurence. This was playing in the snow. Yeah, snow...the no traction white stuff that is supposed to be easy on parts because of that lack of traction.

Posted: February 24, 2007, 7:22 pm
by Slick Fan
That looks like it was a real joy to get back home.

Posted: February 24, 2007, 9:14 pm
by Comet
yeah, two tow trucks. Well, actually 3. The first guy said my rig was too big for his truck (stock hi boy on 33" tires). Then it took two trucks to get in on a rigged up dolly. Thank god for AAA.
Posted: February 25, 2007, 1:34 am
by 64fordf100292v8
Wow! Be used to beat the crap out of my buddies 64 F100 4x4 and never experienced that! We must have gotten lucky because that is awfuly thin. Hope you get it fixed ok.

Posted: February 25, 2007, 12:56 pm
by ICEMAN6166
OUCH!
20+ years using those and some serious mudding and off roading and i never have done that before.
i have blown up a couple ring and pinions in the disc brake fronts but nothing i could not get home on my own.
i replaced the bearings in the knuckles many times, had a few loose ones and worn races but not seen anything like that.
which broke first, the u-joint or the knuckle?
sorry to see that happened to you, no fun for sure.
still i am not going to change any of my front ends because of seeing a broken one.
Posted: February 25, 2007, 6:53 pm
by Comet
Haha! Yeah Ice I didn't think you'd change your mind. I am pretty sure the U joint grenaded first. The axle of course broke too.
64ford, I am "upgrading" (depending on your point of view

) to a '78 F250 axle with high pinion diff and disc brakes. At the same time, I will put in '78 F250 PS and use F350 brake booster and MC. Should be a huge improvement in braking and steering. And, I hope strength. I don't really wheel this thing too hard, that's what I have my Jeep for.
Posted: February 25, 2007, 8:02 pm
by ICEMAN6166
Comet, out of curiosity was that the small or large version of the closed knuckle?
going to part the axle out or just pitch it? i could use a few spare parts. really just the drums, maybe hub/spindles if they are still in good condition.
Posted: February 26, 2007, 12:37 am
by Comet
Ice, it's not the big ball. I was going to take it to the scrap yard. Parts would be a mint to ship, but let me know.
Posted: February 26, 2007, 10:24 am
by 64 f100
You play, you pay. One Oh shit, ruins 100 attaboys every time. I would suspect the u-joint had to be protesting before this happened. Was there no warning sign?
Rich
Posted: February 26, 2007, 11:30 pm
by Comet
Nope, just a big snap! I was done after that. I tried to fix it to get it home, but I couldn't even unlock the front hub. It was bound up too tight and I broke the plastic dial trying. The good news is that this is an upgrade I have been wanting to do and planning for for some time. So I have all the parts for the swap. But it will require some fabbing on the frame for the PS box swap. And, my floor jack just broke too, so I need to go get one before I start on this.
Posted: February 27, 2007, 6:31 am
by jakdad
That does look lika a weak piece but I suspect metal fatigue may have played a part also.

Posted: February 27, 2007, 11:17 am
by The Big M
That's what I was thinking. Do you have a close-up of the failure area, Comet?
Posted: February 27, 2007, 1:06 pm
by ICEMAN6166
guys, that is the failure area. only thing missing is the rest of the lower ear.
there are cone and roller bearings that go in the top and bottom, with a bolt in type "kingpin" in the center,the rest of the casting, spindle and hub are attached to the part in the pic and rotate on the bearings when turning and are held up by them.
i would like to see a pic of the wheels and tires Comet used, as i think they were wider wheels and tire than stock, putting the weight farther out and more strain on the knuckle.
i also dont have plastic knobs on my lockout hubs, they are the stock aluminum ones called hublok.
Posted: February 27, 2007, 1:55 pm
by The Big M
I meant an extreme close-up of where it fractured.
Posted: February 27, 2007, 3:29 pm
by ICEMAN6166
ah, a CSI view of the area.

Posted: February 27, 2007, 3:45 pm
by ripsnorter
heh. oinklette will be happy to hear youre a CSI fan Ice

she loves that show.
there used to be a mudhole next to the freeway near here that we passed a couple of times a week. They played in that thing for several years til one day we went into town we saw an old 70s (dentside I think) hi-boy playing around, on the way back we noticed the same truck all alone in the middle of the mudhole, its front axle laying about 10 yards away. it looked so forlorn sitting there with its nose buried in the mud that it looked like some big lost puppy
for some reason after that they never played there anymore

Posted: February 27, 2007, 4:02 pm
by ICEMAN6166
i used to go play in a hole like that.over the years people lost so many chains and winch cables from breaking when being pulled out when stuck ,when they started wrapping up on our axles and driveshafts we stopped going there too.
Posted: February 27, 2007, 6:01 pm
by The Big M
ICEMAN6166 wrote:ah, a CSI view of the area.

Yes, you could say I aim to
crack the case...

Posted: February 28, 2007, 10:25 pm
by Comet
I'm suspecting there was damage from an earlier incident, not the snow. Just the straw that broke the proverbial camels back. I have never wheeled this thing hard though.
The tires are 33x12.50 BFG AT KOs. New.
Here is the truck:

Posted: March 3, 2007, 12:44 pm
by adrianspeeder
Nice carnage
