Page 1 of 1

3 on the tree vs four on floor

Posted: April 14, 2011, 7:28 am
by greaser
Are there any performance difference? What do people prefer? Cost differences?

Thanks

Posted: April 14, 2011, 8:05 am
by charliemccraney
3 on the tree vs a stock truck 4 speed or a car 4 speed?

Posted: April 14, 2011, 8:18 am
by Casey 65
You can get a top loader overdrive by going to a '84-'85 transmission.

Posted: April 29, 2011, 2:11 pm
by salf100
Is the 84-85 trans a direct bolt in and capable of highway cruising??

Posted: April 29, 2011, 3:58 pm
by matt2491
Thats what I did. Its a near bolt in. You need to drill out one of the top holes (was not completely drilled through the flange from the factory for some reason...) and cut a shifter hole in your floor, and a driveshaft change maybe. Then you're good to go.

Posted: April 29, 2011, 11:28 pm
by Greg D
My vote would be 5 on the floor.
It's what I have, lol.

Posted: April 30, 2011, 8:33 am
by salf100
matt2491, whats your highway crusing like, speeds etc. What shifter did you use?

Posted: May 1, 2011, 8:04 am
by BarnieTrk
Greaser,

If you're looking for a trans just for daily driver use, meaning none to minimal trailer towing or hauling cargo weighing over 1000lbs, then the T170 Series 4-speed Transmission would accomplish that without any difficulty. I'm referring to the T170FT (Code-RTS).
The T170FT is commonly known as a 4-speed/OverDrive (4spd/OD) transmission. They are also known as a TOD (Toploader or Top shift Over Drive (meaning the shifter is on the top - rather than the side -). The T170Ft is a top-loaded 4 speed with 4th being overdrive. It has an aluminum case and shift tower, so it is lighter than the older cast-iron cased 4-speeds. From the information I've gathered, the T170FT were installed in Ford F100-F250 light duty trucks from 1984-85. There were installed into both 2 and 4 wheel drive versions. They were mostly put behind 300” 6cyls and 302 V8s. So to put one behind a warmed over FE engine might not be the best move.

There seem to be two sets of gear ratios possible for the T170FT. They are:
1st: 3.01 / 3.25
2nd: 1.78 / 1.92
3rd: 1.00 / 1.00
4th: 0.79 / 0.78
Rev: 3.01 / 3.25

As you can see, there is a large ratio gap between 1st and 2nd gears. As a result, I find myself reving the engine up more than I normally would before shifting up to 2nd, in an effort to keep the engine lugging to a minimum, depending on load, grade, etc. The T170FT I have has cast in the LH side of the trans: F-E5TR-7006-AA C-2605524. The case length is: 10.25”. The floor shifter comes through at a decent location and looks stock. A custom driveshaft was necessary but can be built and spin balanced without too much effort or $$, between 1-200$. If you have good ends on your current driveshaft the driveshaft guys can use those and keep your cost down. Otherwise, new ends can & likely will run the cost higher. Eitherway, plan on new U-joints.
In my '65 F250 with a 4.10 rear gear, it drives and behaves like a 3 speed, then add an OD. OD is nice if you already have a low-geared (high numerically) rear end like the 4.10 and you plan to drive faster than 60 mph. However, IF you want to tow a two-axle trailer with a tractor/car on it or haul a pallet of shingles, pelletized lime, etc., you will be riding the clutch to get it moving - and especially when backing up - but it may be fine if such towing/hauling frequencies

Now for a working truck, again, in my opinion, the ideal transmission is the T-18 4speed. It is a renowned, heavy-duty truck transmission designed for and used in many ½, 3/4 and 1+ ton Ford, IH or Jeep trucks. This is one of the trannys that is commonly referred to as a 'Granny 4speed", due to the very low first gear. Many drivers do not even use 1st gear when starting out if they are in a no load and/or up grade direction.
The T18 was made by Borg-Warner Gear from 1965 to 1991. It has a T-18 cast in the side of the cast-iron case. The T18 is the improved successor to the T-98 transmission. There was also a T18a transmission, which had a wider gear ratio. The T-18a (wide ratio) gear ratios versus the T18 (close ratio) were:
1st: 6.32 / 4.02
2nd: 3.09 / 2.41
3rd: 1.69 / 1.41
4th: 1.00 / 1.00
Rev: 7.44 / ???

Other things to consider: If you have a "3 in-the-tree" you will NOT have a shifter coming through the floor. If you frequently travel with more than two people the floor shifter can be in the way or if traveling with kids, it can be "something of a mystery" and they tend to want to shift for you or when you don't want shifting to occur! :shock: However, the linkage and steering column collar associated with a 3-speed on the column do wear and need service after 100K miles and occasional lubrication is helpful for them to function and behave properly.

With a car transmission, ensure you are aware where the shifter will come through the floor and the height of the shifter handle. You don't want the shifter to be hitting the dash or the seat or be so low that you are bending down farther than you want to just to reach the shifter!

In deciding which transmission is best for your application - starts with the most basic question: What do I want to do with this truck? Is your intended use for it to be an all around Daily driver, a good-looking but still with GVW-rated capacity of towing/hauling & working capabilities, primarily weekend cruiser, freeway speed cross-country action, side street/stop light action, or a fire-breathing, hot rod wearing a truck skin. Then the next questions are: what rear end gear ratio do I have or am I willing to change the rear gears, what diameter rear tires do I want to use. The secret to a well-balanced vehicle is to ensure all the systems function well together.
I hope the above info helps in your decision-making process! :cheers:
BarnieTrk :steering:

3 on tree sucks even with new parts

Posted: May 1, 2011, 9:08 am
by jhewitt
I had 3 on tree, it was all loose, I got ALL new parts and it wasn't much better, always hanging up from 1st to 2nd. I had purchased TWO of the steering tubes from Carpenter only to have the crappy tab that was spot welded? brake, maybe if you can get sme quality close tolerances replacement parts a 3 om column may be ok