Page 1 of 1

Chrome VS Stainless VS Powder Coat

Posted: March 15, 2015, 7:28 pm
by LM14
Elsewhere I started a thread on chrome platers. Checked with several that were suggested. Some can't do anything as big as a front bumper for a slick but do many smaller parts. Another suggestion that came up was powder coat.

I have had several race car frames powder coated and worked with a couple shops directly doing that. Talked to my 2 favorite powder shops and decided to do an experiment.

I have a complete Heidts Mustang II style IFS setup for my '37 Ford sedan. My upper control arms, stock style lower control arms and rack ends are all polished stainless. The spindles and stock style lower control arm strut rods are show chrome triple plated.

When I got the new crossmember for the '37 frame (I already had the other Heidts pieces on hand), I got the new style that takes a 1 piece lower control arm (strutless). I could get the strutless lower control arms in plain steel for $399.99 about anywhere that sells this kind of stuff. The best price I could find for a pair in polished stainless was $1252.00. Ouch. I bought the cheaper ones and decided to have them powder coated "chrome", just as a comparison.

The pictures below show the difference. The silver looking one is the new "chrome" powder coated piece. The strut rod laying between the 2 control arms is show chrome and the control arm to the right side is polished stainless.

Image
Image
Image
Image

If my crappy pictures show it, the control arm on the left is bright silver and doesn't really look chrome at all (Powder coat), the strut rod in the center has a much more "blue" hue to the finish (show chrome). The control arm to the right has a slightly "yellow" tint to it (polished stainless).

The powder coater said the chrome powder looks just like chrome the first time it gets baked. They then have to put a clear coat on and bake it again to preserve it, or it will not stay nice very long. Since it was a suspension part, he didn't even offer the option of leaving the clear off. When I asked about leaving it off for items in a less severe environment, he just frowned and said he wouldn't stand behind his work if I left off the clear.

To get these 2 control arms triple chrome plated to show chrome standards, to look more like the uppers, would have cost between $225-350 depending on what shop did them. To get them powder coated cost $100 even. To get them in polished stainless, so they absolutely matched the uppers, would have cost $852 more than plain steel. This car will be a driver, I got the original Heidts stainless/chrome/polished aluminum setup for a song (they were updating a show car and the guy just didn't want the stuff lying around his shop). I wasn't about to give more for a set of stainless lower control arms than I gave for all the rest of the suspension (front and rear!). I paid less for all the Heidts parts (uppers, lowers, spindles, rack, coilovers and springs. Everything was either chromed or polished) than the cost of the new style lower control arms. I stole these parts so please don't consider this a high dollar deal. I was just in the right place at the right time. Silver powder coat will be fine for this car. I probably would just have painted them if I bought everything new but I had to at least try to match the shiny parts on the cheap!

Yes, I could have used the original style polished stainless lowers with struts but I wanted more room around the headers and didn't want to mess with the strut mounts on this car.

At least you get to see the 3 finishes compared side by side by side. You make the call for your projects. I won't be powder coating any bumpers to try avoiding chrome hassles.

SPrk

Re: Chrome VS Stainless VS Powder Coat

Posted: March 15, 2015, 8:18 pm
by Toyz
Same thing here; I've had several slick grilles powder coated. We actually experimented with several brands of powder and with/without clear coat. Eastwood admitted to having problems with the original powder; the replacement they provided just did not have satisfactory "gleam" either by itself or clear coated. The "Powder by the LB" brand gave the most chrome-like finish. The clear coated application dulled over time; the non-clear has spots which almost looks as if an animal had relieved itself. ( It would have to have been a rather well-articulated animal; maybe a pissed-off rat :evil: ) My best results so far is the grille I had heavily galvanized, then sanded lightly, buffed out and waxed and polished.
Next experiment will be the spray-on chrome process; I looked at a complete car done with that process; it is not quite as bright as a good chrome, but it appears acceptable for grilles, etc., if it proves durable and maintains the original brilliance.
Paul

Re: Chrome VS Stainless VS Powder Coat

Posted: March 15, 2015, 8:26 pm
by LM14
I've done a lot of reading on the spray on chrome. Not durable at all. The better the clear coat the longer it lasts but you're basically dealing with paint at that point.

SPark

Re: Chrome VS Stainless VS Powder Coat

Posted: March 15, 2015, 10:19 pm
by 6166 Junkyard Dog
several years ago I saw a 66 grill in a truck,, Looked real nice, then when I got to the truck I then seen it was powder coated and It looked nice + I think the powder coating will withstand some of the abuse that is on the front end of these trucks like rock chips,, Last time I saw this process the guy actually took a small hammer and tried to chip it and could not on a A-Arm,, is that still true ?

Re: Chrome VS Stainless VS Powder Coat

Posted: March 16, 2015, 1:58 am
by LM14
Yes, it's pretty tough. I have had race car frames that were folded sideways and it never damaged the powder coat. Much tougher than any regular type wet applied paint. It does have it's weaknesses, though. Once you damage the surface, it will begin to slowly fall apart. It's also harder to touch up when it is damaged or you need to weld on it. No local spotting in, it will need to be baked again to cure new powder.

It's a pain to grind off to make repairs and it smells awful when you do. It will ruin a weld if there is the least little spot left on, got to work to get it all off. Usually touchups in an area repaired just get painted.

A couple of examples:

This brand new car was on it's 3rd night of racing when the RF upper control arm broke at the ball joint holder. The car turned hard right and went nearly head on into the wall at approximately 100 MPH.


Image
Image
Image

I actually straightened the right upper bar and cross bars in front of the engine and re-used them in the new stub we put on. It didn't crack the power around any joints or bends unless the tube actually ripped loose from the adjoining tube. The drawback to that is when you inspect something, it can mask cracks that would show up in normal paint at joints that are stressed. Powder hides that.

This frame was on it's 4th year of racing when these pics were taken. No chips or bad spots seen anywhere. This car has around 60-65 nights on this powder job when these were taken. If you look closely in the side shot right in front of the aluminum strap that is bolted to the lower frame rail, you can see where powder coat was removed to weld a bracket to the lower frame rail, about 6" in front of where all the tubes come together on the lower frame rail.

Image
Image

Good shops blast, then do a phosphate wash of some type, then bake it dry, then apply the powder and bake again to cure. If not, you will get a bad bond. One of the drawback to powder coat is it will begin to lift from an improperly prepared surface. Grease, dirt, even fingerprints will keep it from bonding to the metal. When that happens it will get small cracks in it. These cracks let moisture in and you get rust forming under the powder that you cannot see. By time it shows on the surface, there can be a lot of damage done under the coating. It's much harder to inspect what is below the coating with powder than it is with normal paint.

SPark

Re: Chrome VS Stainless VS Powder Coat

Posted: March 16, 2015, 9:44 am
by bird55
Also if I might add- on the subject of powder coating. Much like show chrome or a show paint job, the better the initial finish and prep the better the final outcome. Get the welding marks smooth, grinder marks gone etc. if you can and you may be happier with the result. And yes PO chrome, isn't really, but does look adequate for some applications. I think grills for one, just because it isn't so shiney of a chrome and looks more like an anodized aluminum and definitely tuff for the long haul.