Page 1 of 2
Ignition issues. 3v from coil under throttle
Posted: December 13, 2015, 6:18 pm
by RRTEC
Seeking assistance. My 289 swapped 1965 F100 is having some issues. It is very sluggish and in general lacks drive ability. I rebuilt the carb, put a new fuel pump, all new fuel lines, plugs wires, etc. checked TDC and set the distributor. I have to run it extremely advanced to get the truck to move really.. It stalls under WOT in gear.
I started checking the ignition system. It has a NAPA TP40 modulator with a harness that connects to a coil, and the distributor. The coil shows about 6-6.5 volts at idle. When any throttle is applied it drops as low as 2.8. Have not been able to check it under load.
To me I feel that I have a problem there. Can anyone explain how the modulator is supposed to work? Is my coil bad? I am going to inspect the harness but I'm not sure what I'm looking at. I can't imagine 3 volts is productive in burning fuel.
Re: Ignition issues. 3v from coil under throttle
Posted: December 13, 2015, 9:22 pm
by Toyz
Lots of possibilities here. My first thought would be to check the wiring for the control box. There are two different Duraspark types with different input voltage requirements and no module/ box interchangeability. I am not certain which the TP40 box is used with. Duraspark II uses a resistor, so can be wired utilizing the original resistance wire. It also has a white wire running to the starter relay "I" terminal, which signals the box to retard timing. DS I requires full battery voltage. Coil input voltage is best tested key on engine off, with voltmeter positive to coil + and negative to ground. Voltage there with DS II should be between 6 to 8 volts. Be aware that a malfunctioning centrifugal advance will often manifest your described symptoms.
Also keep in mind it may NOT be an ignition-related problem, or potentially, a problem in several areas.
Paul
Re: Ignition issues. 3v from coil under throttle
Posted: December 13, 2015, 10:24 pm
by RRTEC
Thanks for the response! I am continuing to troubleshoot. I did find that the secondary coil winding has no resistance. Which would be a major factor.
I will replace the coil tomorrow and see what it does then.
Re: Ignition issues. 3v from coil under throttle
Posted: December 14, 2015, 8:47 am
by SLICKCOLLECTOR
Toyz wrote:Lots of possibilities here. My first thought would be to check the wiring for the control box. There are two different Duraspark types with different input voltage requirements and no module/ box interchangeability. I am not certain which the TP40 box is used with. Duraspark II uses a resistor, so can be wired utilizing the original resistance wire. It also has a white wire running to the starter relay "I" terminal, which signals the box to retard timing. DS I requires full battery voltage. Coil input voltage is best tested key on engine off, with voltmeter positive to coil + and negative to ground. Voltage there with DS II should be between 6 to 8 volts. Be aware that a malfunctioning centrifugal advance will often manifest your described symptoms.<br abp="230">Also keep in mind it may NOT be an ignition-related problem, or potentially, a problem in several areas.<br abp="231">Paul
Is that original resistance wire on the Duraspark 2 voltage required for both the ignition control module and coil? I am running a full 12 volts to both the brain box and the coil? it starts fantastic but what is the downside to running the full 12 volts? thanks.
Re: Ignition issues. 3v from coil under throttle
Posted: December 14, 2015, 4:52 pm
by RRTEC
Well replaced the coil and reworked the harness. Some change, not much.
Modulator next?
Re: Ignition issues. 3v from coil under throttle
Posted: December 14, 2015, 7:21 pm
by Toyz
In my opinion, it's STILL test next! I don't like changing parts because they MIGHT be the problem. You may in fact find a mismatch which may well cause the symptoms to repeat with new parts. Which brings us to Jim's query. With DS 2, module AND coil life will often be greatly shortened by the full battery voltage. Note I did not say "full 12 volts", simply because charging voltage while running will usually exceed that. Heat is the enemy of electronic parts, and more voltage often relates to increased heat. Often the problems with these change-overs are mis-matched parts. IF you have a coil with a significant internal resistance, it may do well with full available voltage. DS1 systems are the exception. Those are designed for full voltage at both module and coil; with a very low resistance! the reason for this is the design of the DS1 module; and thus the reason for no interchangeability with DS II components other than distributor. This system is hard to find and more expensive than the DSII, but arguably the best performance ignition Ford has ever furnished, and vastly superior to the infamous HEI,with it's very poor performance at rpm's exceeding around 4400. Thus, if you are certain that your ignition is DSII, and has a compatible coil, you are certainly better off in most cases, with a 1.1 ohm resistor and the original coil's 1.17 ohm primary resistance.
Hope this helps both of you!
Paul
Re: Ignition issues. 3v from coil under throttle
Posted: December 14, 2015, 8:12 pm
by RRTEC
I really appreciate your input although am lost in the terminology. I am going to have to research the terms and systems you are referencing.
Re: Ignition issues. 3v from coil under throttle
Posted: December 14, 2015, 8:16 pm
by RRTEC
My truck has a painless harness, there is one ignition wire going to the coil, and the rest of the modulator harness feeds off that and then to the distributor. No other wires at all from anywhere.
Re: Ignition issues. 3v from coil under throttle
Posted: December 14, 2015, 8:24 pm
by Toyz
That is potentially two problems already! Need to see if you can determine coil primary resistance, or let me know the part number if available. Bottom line is, with the TP40, you need a 1.1 ohm resistor, and most likely need about the same resistance for the coil. What is the color code on the modulator box?
Paul
Re: Ignition issues. 3v from coil under throttle
Posted: December 14, 2015, 10:38 pm
by RRTEC
As a rule out I did buy a replacement modulator. The truck is running better but is not right.
I de-loomed the harness and here is what I currently know: the module is a blue plug replacement module.
The ground ring from the coil connects to the green wire at the module
The 12v from the ignition switch runs directly to the coil, coupled with 1 power wire from the module.
There is a second power wire to the module that is cut off / disconnected.
There is no ground for the coil so I assume it is through the coil body or the module body? Or should I add one to the block?
Re: Ignition issues. 3v from coil under throttle
Posted: December 14, 2015, 10:40 pm
by RRTEC
I am running an accel 8140 seems to have a 1.8k ohm resistance on the primary winding.
Re: Ignition issues. 3v from coil under throttle
Posted: December 15, 2015, 7:19 am
by Toyz
That combo complicates things a little. The Accel will work well with full available battery voltage, while reduced voltage is recommended for the blue module. I will look at the wire colors ths evening; I suspect the module power may be provided by the white wire. This would effectively retard the timing. With your setup, the easiest fix is probably an in-line resistor in the correct module power supply wire, as well as a substantial ground at the module. Coil does not require an external ground. Personally, I would leave the white wire disconnected unless the starter bogs down. The new modulator could have already been damaged by the excess voltage, but I would consider that unlikely.
Again, good luck!
Paul
Re: Ignition issues. 3v from coil under throttle
Posted: December 15, 2015, 10:10 am
by RRTEC
Thanks again, so I will add a 1.1ohm resistor between the coil and the modulator tonight, as well as add a ground to the modulator and report back.
Thanks for the help!
Re: Ignition issues. 3v from coil under throttle
Posted: December 15, 2015, 11:06 am
by Toyz
Be certain that the modulator power is NOT the white wire!
Paul
Re: Ignition issues. 3v from coil under throttle
Posted: December 15, 2015, 12:34 pm
by RRTEC
Ok will do. What happens if that is the case?
The coil shows 6.5 volts so the resistor is on the ignition wire, the resistor still needs to be on the power wire to the module correct?
Re: Ignition issues. 3v from coil under throttle
Posted: December 15, 2015, 2:51 pm
by Toyz
White wire sends a retard signal to the module while starting. If it is hot in run position, ignition will be retarded as much as ten degrees. With that high resistance coil, you should need full charging system voltage for optimum performance. So, if yo are seeing 6.5 at coil positive with coil negative grounded, you can run your resistance wire solely to module and "y" off before resistance wire (or resistor)!for full available coil feed voltage.
Paul
Re: Ignition issues. 3v from coil under throttle
Posted: December 15, 2015, 8:13 pm
by RRTEC
Ok,
The white wire is not connected. Apparently I do not have 6 volts at the coil I have 12v when the module is disconnected. Yesterday I had accidently put the leads on the new coil in reverse (accel apparently changed the sticker location on my coil) Oops.
I traced the wiring back and there is no resistor wire or anything just straight battery voltage to the coil.
Tried to buy a resistor today but was lacking some info. I am not sure what the amp/watt draw of the module is, so I don't know what duty 1.1k ohm resistor to buy.
Re: Ignition issues. 3v from coil under throttle
Posted: December 15, 2015, 10:25 pm
by Toyz
Your measurement is with the coil negative terminal securely grounded? Box draw is around 3/5 amps max. My preferred solution would be to purchase an OEM resistance wire available at most auto parts for the '66 application, and route it without shortening from wire going to coil positive to the box power wire. A 1.1 ohm ceramic ballast resistor can also be easily obtained.
I am beginning to believe your symptoms may be independent of the Duraspark if you actually had full battery voltage to both coil and correct wire at box.
Paul
Re: Ignition issues. 3v from coil under throttle
Posted: December 15, 2015, 10:33 pm
by RRTEC
I'm going to go back and check timing, and the carb setup. I bought a vacuum gauge to really dial that in.
Re: Ignition issues. 3v from coil under throttle
Posted: December 16, 2015, 7:10 am
by Toyz
I would suggest checking total advance and vacuum hoses routing just to verify.
Paul