Page 1 of 1
Red Light Cameras are about money, not safety
Posted: February 22, 2008, 10:26 pm
by Doug
Red light cameras and unmanned speed cameras are rapidly spreading across the U.S. and are fleecing millons of dollars from people who had no intention of breaking the law. Folks need to learn the dirty truth behind them. You guys in Canada already know this. The people who are cashing the checks say "I'ts only for your safety", but they stack the deck to trick you into violations. Learn why they are
causing accidents instead of preventing them. Visit www.thenewspaper.com search "Red Light Cameras" and "Popular Studies" then tell your local officials that you are on to them. I once thought, since I don't run red lights, they are no concern of mine.
Posted: February 22, 2008, 10:41 pm
by Greg D
Didn't need a news article to figure this one out. Typical government, "follow the money", lots of revenue + basically 0 man hours to produce it. They are illegal in Nebraska otherwise known as the "tax me" state (one of the few things this state gets right).
I think I am getting some of these.
http://licenseplatecovers.info/
Posted: February 22, 2008, 11:32 pm
by dotcentral
I agree, a huge scam. When we first got them in Charlotte, NC about 7 years or so ago, one person fought the ticket and was able to get a city traffic engineer to admit they cut the duration of the yellow light at that intersection from about 5 seconds to 3 seconds when they installed the camera. I think that guy won his case, but not 100% on that.
But the best thing was the state sued the municipalities with these cameras, like Charlotte, because the state of North Carolina is required by law to get a certain percentage of all traffic infraction fines. And the cities weren't paying the state. Charlotte's lame excuse was something along the lines of by the time they gave the cut to the private company that installed, owned, and monitored these cameras, there was only a small percentage left for the city. And if the city gave the state their intitlement, the city would actually loose money. So they tried to argue since a private company was doing all this and not law enforcement, the state wasn't entitled to anything. Well, Charlotte lost that case and owes the state a huge amount of money. No idea if it's been paid yet.
This was in the papers, TV and radio down here quite a bit when this hit the fan. And it sounds like a hell of a racket for the private companies that install these things. the cities only seem to get a small percentage. And to increase revenues they seem to do things like change the duration of green and yellow lights. Plus the increase in accidents, the ill will of the general population, it hardly seems worth it.
Posted: February 23, 2008, 1:00 am
by MrEvil
Amarillo is going to install SIX of the redlight cameras....this after our rotten [expletive deleted] mayor said we were only getting THREE. She flat-out lied to us and to top it all off the city is in with this company for FIVE YEARS! And the city knew going in they weren't going to make any money off the cameras. Amarillo agrees to the [expletive deleted] things not two weeks after Lubbock decides to get rid of them.
Not only that, but there were MANY people that showed up to the city meeting to protest the cameras and they brought with them studies from the Federal DoT as well as the DoTs of other states saying that the cameras just traded t-bones for rear end collisions.
I think I'm going to have to rig up some kind of solar powered laser pointers to aim at the traffic cameras or go around sticking shock site images over the lenses to give the boys at ATS a face full of things they can't un-see.
In England they hate speed cameras so much they firebomb them.
Posted: February 23, 2008, 2:56 am
by ICEMAN6166
MrEvil wrote:Amarillo is going to install SIX of the redlight cameras....this after our rotten [expletive deleted] mayor said we were only getting THREE. She flat-out lied to us and to top it all off the city is in with this company for FIVE YEARS! And the city knew going in they weren't going to make any money off the cameras. Amarillo agrees to the [expletive deleted] things not two weeks after Lubbock decides to get rid of them.
Not only that, but there were MANY people that showed up to the city meeting to protest the cameras and they brought with them studies from the Federal DoT as well as the DoTs of other states saying that the cameras just traded t-bones for rear end collisions.
I think I'm going to have to rig up some kind of solar powered laser pointers to aim at the traffic cameras or go around sticking shock site images over the lenses to give the boys at ATS a face full of things they can't un-see.
In England they hate speed cameras so much they firebomb them.
sounds like you folks need to get rid of the mayor and make her pay the company for 5 years.
Posted: February 23, 2008, 7:45 am
by Doug
When I very first heard about these things I thought they might be a good idea, because I hate to see people blow through red lights. Like everything else that involves a lot of money, they get crooked in order to CREATE red light running to make MORE money. The vast majority of tickets are generated by a light that has been red less than 2/10 of a second! Most people who cause bad T-bones do so because they are not familiar with the intersection and just did not see the light. Cameras are doing almost nothing to reduce T-bones but are causing huge increases in rear-enders. Several towns here in Ohio have made petitons that force it to a vote. Every time folks have had a chance to vote on this issue, the camera carpetbaggers have been run out of town. Too many people still believe the "safety" hype that the camera companys are spewing out. Tell your friends..
Posted: February 23, 2008, 8:12 am
by DV65CustomCab
http://www.motorists.org/photoenforce/
If you've got red light cameras in your area, hook up with this organization. They can provide all the tech you need to fight them in court or at the local planning level. I've been a member since the 1980s. If it weren't for the NMA, we'd still have a 55 mph national speed limit.

Posted: February 23, 2008, 5:19 pm
by Doug
DV65---- I do belong to the NMA, There are a lot of seperate fights going on to stop the cameras here in Ohio. NMA has a lot of solid facts condeming RLC's but strangely does'nt seem to have a presence in any of these battles. I just sent them an E-mail 3 days ago and asked them why. I have not recieved an answer yet. ----- By the way, I LIKE long beds, they ride nicer and haul longer stuff!!! Long beds are what everybody drove around here when I was growing up and slick sixties were late model trucks. Where my brother lives in Georgia, every body drove short beds,, Go figure!!!
Posted: February 23, 2008, 8:04 pm
by FORDBOYpete
Y'all are so right. If I came up with a money maker scheme like that they'd bust my butt 4-Sure. Down here rear end collisions have increased in intersections where the "cameras" are. People slam on the brakes at caution or yellow. People behind them have no warning and no chance & can't avoid hitting them, Guess who gets the citation
( AHhh Eerr ? More Money for the system maybe? )

Mr Evil,
Just make a counterfiet copy of your mayor's wifes car tag & run every redlight you can find in as many cars & trucks as possible for a while.
As long as "BIG BRo" is busy watching with his cameras the rollers are not, they do "other police duties" instead. By the time they figure it out the Mayor's wife will not have her D/L anymore, and won't find out until she gets stopped or tries to renew it. It's cruel but effective tatics.
Here in the BiKiNi State we have a thing called Sun Pass that uses a transponder to pay tolls & fees as vehicles pass a scanner. They started pulling peoples DL's for alleged "non payment of "fines" they supposedly
"Mailed" to the victims, but none of the victims ever got notified or a citation or a bill for the fine, but they were paying their "SunPass" billed invoices just all along.

DUH?
150 or so people hit the "proverbial fan" for having their DL's suspended without any warning. 1 got stopped for driving without a license which he had in his wallet, and had recently just renewed on his Birthday a week or so before. All of a sudden all these other people came out of the wood work. Seems a cameras were taking pictures even though their system scanned the transponder signals as paid. . . . . .

Duh Again!
Then the DDL wants them to pay a $100 fine for having DL's suspended, even tho' it was an illegal suspension based on a faulty system glitch. . . . MONEY MAKER? I Guess Maybe you are spot on with that concept.
Me?
I stop & pay the toll, often with loose change & pennies if I have them. I really put a kink in traffic sometimes. What I can't grasp is how do they know who's driving the vehicle by the tag number? Right they don't.
My buddy got a citation for running a red light with his mustang while he was in Europe on business. Trouble is his car was parked in the parking lot at OIA (Orlando Inatl Airport), ah they were forced dismissed that one I believe. There is some justice I guess, Huh?
FBp 
Posted: February 24, 2008, 11:38 am
by Doug
Ford boy---- One of the real tradgedies of this scam, is that all the camera company had to do to declare him guilty, is mail the ticket. How much trouble did he have to go thru to prove he was innocent of this absurd charge? Whether it's over red light cameras or anything else, Our loss of the right to be "Innocent until proven guilty" is a really big deal, it is frightening, and people need to speak up before they loose "free speach" next. Imagine if the police knock on your door today and tell you " It has been determined that you are guilty of treason. Can you prove to us that you are not?" I don't mean to sound like a wacko, but mailing you a photo ticket is the same thing, just a different issue!
Posted: February 24, 2008, 12:05 pm
by ICEMAN6166
Doug wrote:Ford boy---- One of the real tradgedies of this scam, is that all the camera company had to do to declare him guilty, is mail the ticket. How much trouble did he have to go thru to prove he was innocent of this absurd charge? Whether it's over red light cameras or anything else, Our loss of the right to be "Innocent until proven guilty" is a really big deal, it is frightening, and people need to speak up before they loose "free speach" next. Imagine if the police knock on your door today and tell you " It has been determined that you are guilty of treason. Can you prove to us that you are not?" I don't mean to sound like a wacko, but mailing you a photo ticket is the same thing, just a different issue!

Posted: February 24, 2008, 1:46 pm
by didgeytrucker
There have been several "cameras" installed in my area, but not on my usual paths. So I've been watching ALL lights more carefully and hitting the brakes at the first hint of a yellow. I've had one car pass me in the ditch, one car passed me (going straight) in the left turn lane and one 18 wheeler slam on his brakes and lay on his horn. I had to roll through the intersection to avoid being hit by the 18 wheeler. I went back later and looked at his skid marks. His front wheels stopped where mine should have!
Yes, the "cameras" make me fell safer - NOT!
When my 1978 F-150 is about to bite the dust, I'm gonna get it hit in the rear at one of these lights.
Tracy
Posted: February 25, 2008, 10:17 am
by FORDBOYpete
I think maybe it's because it's
much harder to prove a "negative" or
Non-Event that never happened, than prove it did. I have a rough time proving I didn't do something, or wasn't someplace, & so forth. . .
So now we're assumed guilty until we prove otherwise ?
Here's what's wrong with latter day Techno - Systems. Equipment can not testify, nor can it be cross examined, nor can it be assumed to be correct all the time.

In addition there's no way of knowing if it was tampered with or abused someway. Don't we all have technical things that didn't work correctly once in a while?
The image shows a vehicle with a traceable tag number going thru an intersection. . . . Yeah, And So What? They are not in color, seldom if ever, show the light as being red ( saying instead; "Oh? Well, a camera only works when the light's red so the light had to be red for the picture to be taken.") What about Photo Shop? Doesn't the fact that Photo Shop even exists sort of blow the notion of a "Fail Safe" digital imaging system away?
I could set up a camera at an intersection, take pix of any vehicle as it passes thru the intersection legally, photo shop a tag on it, & accuse it of running a red light. Does not mean it ever happened? Not really, but the accused will have a hard time proving otherwise, in most cases. . . More importantly, how does it show who is actually operating the vehicle & committing the act that's in question? The accused might be penalized for committing an act they were, in fact, never actually part of. All they did was own the vehicle, or have their name on the registration or title.
We have not been cited via Snail Mail for any traffic infraction, violation, or offense since we started putting 2 or more names on all of our fiscal properties & Documents. IE Bank accounts, property, vehicles Titles and/ or regitrations, etc. etc. We do that for tax & other purposes. But a REAL side benefit seems to be, we can't both be charged with committing the same offense while driving a vehicle cited by a "Techno Device".
Vehicles certainly are not fiscally responsible for traffic violations, so who does or should the bureacratic system go after?
Anal (or methodical as I call it) as it might seem, when we rent vehicles we put both our names on that contract also. . . . . How can anybody even think of accusng both people of simultaenously committing a traffic infraction tigether ? ?

Right! It's Not happening. . . . .
I own a few Semi's. One of my drivers receives a traffic violation. The city gets my name from DMV & sends me a citation. I will send it back telling them to take it up with the driver they suspect was who committed their offense. All I do is own the vehicles all my drivers drive. I insure against damages, but I am not responsible for driver errors or mistakes made while operating my vehicles, other than being sure everything is in legal order, in a responsible, current, manner. Our system counts on people not fighting injustice. All our governments, from Municipal to County, to State, to Federal are all getting worse about crossing the line into areas of injustice our constitution actually has authority to protect us against.
They all do so to support their own extravagances & do so at the expense of "
We The People" [WE actually are supposed to be the soverigns in our system of self government] See now? I payed attention in Civics Class. but we are expreiencing "Mission Creep" to keep the present system fat & happy. . . . . and what is our system doing for us?
Why it's devising new and egregious ways to take advantage of our good nature and Dummbed Down Educational system.
AAAaaRrrrghh.. . . .

I gotta go take Blood Pressure medication now
FBp . . . . . .

Posted: February 25, 2008, 11:21 am
by ICEMAN6166
FORDBOYpete wrote:
Our system counts on people not fighting injustice. All our governments, from Municipal to County, to State, to Federal are all getting worse about crossing the line into areas of injustice our constitution actually has authority to protect us against.
They all do so to support their own extravagances & do so at the expense of "We The People" [WE actually are supposed to be the soverigns in our system of self government] See now? I payed attention in Civics Class. but we are expreiencing "Mission Creep" to keep the present system fat & happy. . . . . and what is our system doing for us?
Why it's devising new and egregious ways to take advantage of our good nature and Dummbed Down Educational system.
Pete, that is telling it like it is.
i would vote for you but i am not sure the electronic voting machine would record it accurately.

Posted: February 25, 2008, 6:11 pm
by Doug
Ford Boy-- I know this is hard to believe--- A photo ticket in Ohio finds your VEHICLE guilty. The owner is responsible for his vehicle's behavior even if he is home in bed. Kinda like if your dog bites your neighbor while you're taking a nap, --you just comitted a crime in your sleep! As I said in my first post, Check out
www.thenewspaper.com search "photo enforcement" , "red light cameras" and "popular studies" -----Take your blood pressure medicine first! Ordinary folks who don't usually mess in politics have
GOT to e-mail their mayor and city council members and tell them
NO . A few of them actually believe the camera vendors and think it will reduce accidents. And all that money is just icing on the cake!
Posted: February 26, 2008, 11:54 am
by FORDBOYpete
Nah, Doug, really I can & DO believe it. . . . .
I was cited doing 70 in a 55 in my "diesel PeterCar" on 0h-10's Turnpike a long time ago. I was running eastbound with a 40K lb load of Mars candy bars out of Chicago. I was running right at 70Mph & holding it at the time, baiting bears, to break up the monotony of the "Buckeye Blvd."
The 0h-10 sign said:
SPEED LIMIT 70 MPH
Trucks over 2 tons when empty 55 MPH
Soon an 0h-10 Bear came after me. I drove until I came up to a "speed limit sign", then pulled over. I took a polaroid of the sign as it was. The bear approached, I took his pic, and 1 of his cruiser too. He went thru' a usual spiel before running me off to a Judge to pay my "bail" [read that as fine]. I got my Log book, manifest, BOL (Bill of lading) & polaroid Pics of sign & all involved in my being stopped that day. The usual court room banter went on and I was asked how I pleaded. Of course I was not guilty. Judge" Asked me how fast I was going. I said 70Mph sir.
Then you are guilty driver.
{I'm thinking Ah But. . . . au Contrere sir}
I'm not empty you see. I'm loaded with candy bars, Sir. Here's my manifest with a time /date stamp & weight receipt also. Here is my log book too.
What's your point Driver? Your truck weighs well over 2 tons when it's empty. You were going 70mph by your own admission, that makes you guilty as charged.
"I beg to differ sir, I am not empty so speed limit for me is 70Mph & that's what I was driving at." Here see for yourself & handed him my polaroids. He took them, checked them, then said "
That's Not what the sign means driver. . . .
It means if your vehicle weighs over 2 tons when it's empty you must run at 55Mph".
Well that's not what it says, Sir. It clearly says
"When Empty" as you just said also. Fact is I am not empty. So the sign says I can go 70. I can't see how it means anything else when read correctly.
My load is 20 tons of candy bars. That's way over 2 tons plus. Proving I'm not empty empty. A sign with the Adverb "WHEN" is time specific, and this time I'm proved to clearly be not empty. If your sign was to say
Speed Limits Vehicles with a ULW over 2 Tons 55Mph, then I would be guilty. So I am not guilty based on the wording of your sign. I fail to comply with both of the two criteria, being empty & weighing over two tons, for going 55, at least as your sign describes them.
Needless to say The Judge thought a moment, chuckled, laughed, then said you have presented a good defense Driver. I'll dismiss these charges on that basis. But the intent is to have large trucks go 55 Mph. Thank You your Honor, I appreciate your honesty.
Of course on ride back in the police cruiser I got a "butt Reaming" from the 0h-10 Trooper, along with a warning not to spread the results around. I ignored that as I "CB'd" a message to the world. 6Mos later 0h-10 changed their Tpke Signs by removing "When" from the message.
It was back in the days of Monfort meat haulers out of Colorado in their Yellow & Red "Hot Rod" Peterbilt 359's. In fact they're who the passing or "hammer lane" was named for when it was known as Monfort Lane.
Needless to say I don't run 0h-10, just as I avoid the east coast north of North Carolina, anymore. Terrible roads, dangerous traffic, too many 4 wheelers with no sense &too many ridiculous laws & entrapment schemes, plus a concentrated effort to "boost" or rip off truckers any way they can, illegally or otherwise. I don't need all that grief, STRESS & Heatrtburn. I can't afford the fines with diesel at $3.65/gal either.
It's all a huge moneymaking "BOHICA" {aka Bend Over Here It Comes Again}! Oh Well
FBp

Posted: February 26, 2008, 9:34 pm
by Rosati
Just get your rear bumbers build out of drill stem (preferably a three row minimum) and slam away at the brakes. Getting hit from the rear is not a tickartable offense and your truck will be unharmed.
Note:
I tried to find a pic of some absurdly large rear bumper, but no luck. Use your own MadLibs tyoe imagination.

Posted: March 28, 2008, 2:59 pm
by Johnny Canuck
They are doing a "Study" of these devices in my town right now. First, the local paper came out against them in an Editorial. Then, in agreement, I wrote this:
http://www.lethbridgeherald.com/article_10288.php
to the editor. I also sent a version of it to all the city councillors and the Mayor.
and, if they start seriously going for them I WILL be starting that petiton.

Posted: March 28, 2008, 5:52 pm
by Xcessive
FORDBOYpete wrote:Nah, Doug, really I can & DO believe it. . . . .
I was cited doing 70 in a 55 in my "diesel PeterCar" on 0h-10's Turnpike a long time ago. I was running eastbound with a 40K lb load of Mars candy bars out of Chicago. I was running right at 70Mph & holding it at the time, baiting bears, to break up the monotony of the "Buckeye Blvd."
The 0h-10 sign said:
SPEED LIMIT 70 MPH
Trucks over 2 tons when empty 55 MPH
Soon an 0h-10 Bear came after me. I drove until I came up to a "speed limit sign", then pulled over. I took a polaroid of the sign as it was. The bear approached, I took his pic, and 1 of his cruiser too. He went thru' a usual spiel before running me off to a Judge to pay my "bail" [read that as fine]. I got my Log book, manifest, BOL (Bill of lading) & polaroid Pics of sign & all involved in my being stopped that day. The usual court room banter went on and I was asked how I pleaded. Of course I was not guilty. Judge" Asked me how fast I was going. I said 70Mph sir.
Then you are guilty driver.
{I'm thinking Ah But. . . . au Contrere sir}
I'm not empty you see. I'm loaded with candy bars, Sir. Here's my manifest with a time /date stamp & weight receipt also. Here is my log book too.
What's your point Driver? Your truck weighs well over 2 tons when it's empty. You were going 70mph by your own admission, that makes you guilty as charged.
"I beg to differ sir, I am not empty so speed limit for me is 70Mph & that's what I was driving at." Here see for yourself & handed him my polaroids. He took them, checked them, then said "
That's Not what the sign means driver. . . .
It means if your vehicle weighs over 2 tons when it's empty you must run at 55Mph".
Well that's not what it says, Sir. It clearly says
"When Empty" as you just said also. Fact is I am not empty. So the sign says I can go 70. I can't see how it means anything else when read correctly.
My load is 20 tons of candy bars. That's way over 2 tons plus. Proving I'm not empty empty. A sign with the Adverb "WHEN" is time specific, and this time I'm proved to clearly be not empty. If your sign was to say
Speed Limits Vehicles with a ULW over 2 Tons 55Mph, then I would be guilty. So I am not guilty based on the wording of your sign. I fail to comply with both of the two criteria, being empty & weighing over two tons, for going 55, at least as your sign describes them.
Needless to say The Judge thought a moment, chuckled, laughed, then said you have presented a good defense Driver. I'll dismiss these charges on that basis. But the intent is to have large trucks go 55 Mph. Thank You your Honor, I appreciate your honesty.
Of course on ride back in the police cruiser I got a "butt Reaming" from the 0h-10 Trooper, along with a warning not to spread the results around. I ignored that as I "CB'd" a message to the world. 6Mos later 0h-10 changed their Tpke Signs by removing "When" from the message.
It was back in the days of Monfort meat haulers out of Colorado in their Yellow & Red "Hot Rod" Peterbilt 359's. In fact they're who the passing or "hammer lane" was named for when it was known as Monfort Lane.
Needless to say I don't run 0h-10, just as I avoid the east coast north of North Carolina, anymore. Terrible roads, dangerous traffic, too many 4 wheelers with no sense &too many ridiculous laws & entrapment schemes, plus a concentrated effort to "boost" or rip off truckers any way they can, illegally or otherwise. I don't need all that grief, STRESS & Heatrtburn. I can't afford the fines with diesel at $3.65/gal either.
It's all a huge moneymaking "BOHICA" {aka Bend Over Here It Comes Again}! Oh Well
FBp

lol nice story there... DId you live in colorado and drive for monfort? My granddad was a safety directer for Monfort, shupe, steinbecker, and tri-state commoditities and when it was around Asbury construction...
Oh and he was the one that started the daytime driving lights with Coors. he was their head fleet safety in the 60's and 70's.
Maybe you knew him?
I still know most of the old drivers from those companies and look at em as family still.