Page 1 of 2
American Military Jet "Made In France"??????
Posted: March 2, 2008, 5:46 pm
by Greg D
This was in one of my Mustang forums:
I’m sure some of you must have heard abut this.
I‘m pissed and I don’t even work for Boeing.
http://www.king5.com/topstories/stor...P.cefbf89.html
Not only is this deal bad for our country’s economy, but I think it goes against the ITAR. ITAR stands for the International Trade in Arms Agreement. These regulations were put in place for American suppliers of equipment and technology. This regulates and governs what technical stuff can be sold to foreign countries. It also covers that anything sold to the US Government. Anything sold to the US Government has to be supported by an American manufacturer. With US military equipment suppliers must be able to be counted on as a stable and dependable source for replacement parts as well as accountability. How and why can a US military tanker jet be designed and built by a company in France? If France were to go under attack or overtaken by a foreign country our supply of replacement parts for this military aircraft is now in peril! This is not like finding out that a brake caliper you need for your Fiat is now on backorder! THOSE BASTARDS!
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Interna...ms_Regulations
Posted: March 2, 2008, 6:55 pm
by blackagatha
SERIOUS MAN, I couldn't have said it better myself. I was considerable pissed when I heard about that plan... WTF... It makes all together zero sense... From a economic, security, or parts point of view... (disgusted)
Posted: March 2, 2008, 7:11 pm
by Max
It's a huge contract and all about the green. Airbus holds a little more gas. We are already doing the same thing with the AV8 Harrier, T45 Goshawk, and recently the T6 Texan II's - as far as foreign design, US manufactured hardware.
The Northrop/EADs have as much American workshare as the Boeing products. Many American made components go into most of the Airbus jets, just like numerous non-American made components go into a Boeing jet.
Personally, I'd rather see Boeing get it too but this is a very capable aircraft for the USAF.
Posted: March 2, 2008, 8:34 pm
by Greg D
The Harrier is kind of a different gig though it's made here under license. I had to search the Texan II - Tucano.
Posted: March 2, 2008, 9:31 pm
by Max
Posted: March 3, 2008, 12:53 pm
by Johnny Canuck
Could be worse. Walmart could be in charge of ordering and they'd be made in China.
Have names like Grohmann, and Bowing.

Posted: March 3, 2008, 1:09 pm
by GLindley
Johnny Canuck wrote:Could be worse. Walmart could be in charge of ordering and they'd be made in China.
Have names like Grohmann, and Bowing.

Yeah, and then they'd all be recalled because of too much lead on the paint...
Posted: March 3, 2008, 3:34 pm
by ICEMAN6166
government contracts are based on $ and timetable for completion. hopefully this one turns out properly within the budget with no recalls or other problems.
Posted: March 3, 2008, 4:24 pm
by Greg D
I guess I am still seeing a difference in a foreign design built under license by an American manufacturer and a plane built by a foreign manufacturer. A good design is a good design, issue to me is where it's built. We have been sharing aircraft designs back and forth with our allies since WWI, nothing new and it's all good. After all the P-51 Mustang was powered by a Packard built Rolls Royce engine and look how that turned out. But like the article stated, what happens if they get invaded and we lose our parts supplier? If we build spares under license here that might be OK but someone should be saying something about this.
Posted: March 3, 2008, 5:50 pm
by Max
This one will be built (assembled) in Mobile, Alabama.
Who would want to invade France? Besides, if the crap really hit the fan - we always have the loser in the deal.
There are already a few head-spinning, defense dept. decisions that make this one quite pale in comparison like Lockheed selling a higher advanced F16 to a middle eastern country (UAE) than what our own Air Force is buying & operating.
It's all politics. Let's see how fast Sarkozy lends us support next time we ask for it.
Posted: March 3, 2008, 6:22 pm
by Greg D
Max wrote:This one will be built (assembled) in Mobile, Alabama.
Well see that's different. One of the things I was considering is everytime France gets into a war, they surrender. 
Military Tanker
Posted: March 3, 2008, 9:43 pm
by Mike P
I am a Boeing KC-135 Crew Chief. The only thing assembled in the USA is the refueling boom and some internal accessories. The Aircraft is made in europe and assembled in France. The engines are at least made in the USA (GE CF-6). But I have worked on KC-135's and KC-10's for 22 years and I can't believe that SCARE BUS is going to build our new tanker.
[/b]I'LL bet that as soon as you take it to combat it will surrender

Posted: March 3, 2008, 10:14 pm
by blackagatha
Max wrote:
There are already a few head-spinning, defense dept. decisions that make this one quite pale in comparison like Lockheed selling a higher advanced F16 to a middle eastern country (UAE) than what our own Air Force is buying & operating.
DUH, WHAT?!?! THAT seems like a bad idear.... WTF mate?
government contracts are based on $ and timetable for completion
really? since when? what I see generally appears to be billions over budget and years behind the project deadline... does it not? or am i just insane?
Posted: March 3, 2008, 10:25 pm
by Max
Mike P, what unit are you in & where? I just went on my 3rd flight with the 134th ARW from Tennessee. Taking pics over the Gulf of our F16's from 147th FW.
military jet
Posted: March 3, 2008, 10:40 pm
by Mike P
I'm with the 151st ARW Salt Lake City Utah
Posted: March 4, 2008, 9:20 am
by FORDBOYpete
Are these French built Military aircraft capable of backward or sideways flight in case they're confronted from the front, OUI ?
Anyone know if this "Scare Bus" designed unit has a unique French, Dual Slave, steering gear, set up, where Hyd Sys is neutral
on balanced +psi but operates on imbalance (actually pressure loss or -Psi) vs pressure increase to effect front steering?
I'm totally mind boggled how A-Bus front gear cramps @ 180* to opposite side when a slave cyl goes bad.
I think I understand French engineering logic for this strange technique,
A, they want to save money on pressure control valves.
B, they haven't figured out how to plumb a reduntant system yet.
C, they they want it to skid straight in case of failure & know how Frenchmen act in a crisis so pilot control is denied.
Y'all recall that A380 sliding along, blowing out a rooster tail of sparks & ground up metal shards into the intakes on LAX a while back?
Or worse, recall a Concord lifting off Orly that ran over metal debris, blew a couple of tires on a port truck, ruptured a fuel cell & ingested tires & associated debris thru a port intake, then spiraled into a motel 1/2 a Km ahead in a ball of flames?
More French Design?
After that fiasco, no more Concords, OUI ?
Nobody mentions how elevated envelope temperatures @ sustained Supersonic Flight in atmosphere, tends to degrade & kill wiring and hyd' system comopnents either. . . . OUI ?
So now we're Globalizing Safety of U.S. Personnel & Quality of equipment U.S. personnel have to use for the sake of saving what, a few dollars?
Hellfire U.S. dollars aren't worth anything anymore anyway.
Like It takes more than 3 of them to get a gallon of gasoline, loaf of decent bread, or a gallon of milk each. It takes 6 to buy a pound of beef. . . .
Yowie!! It's another
B O H I C A
FBp 
Posted: March 4, 2008, 10:06 am
by Johnny Canuck
Imagine living in Canada, where in 1958 we had the
Avro Arrow, which would run circles around anything NATO had at the time. They were shooting for Mach 2 in it and damn near had it, when, a change of government, and pressure from the US, who didn't have anything to touch it,( and were
whiny jealous,cry.gif ) got it cancelled.
They cut all the Arrows up into tiny pieces and tried to forget about the whole thing. Ever since, all our military have had for planes are ones designed and made elsewhere. Usually, by the only country that has
ever attacked Canada on Canadian soil. Makes a whole heap of sense, eh?
Politicians. The things you see when you don't have a gun
At least it worked out good for you guys. The big minds at Avro all went to NASA, and were instrumental in bringing around the Lunar landing. Some also went to Concorde.
Posted: March 4, 2008, 9:59 pm
by Mike P
If you will notice in 1954 the F-104 Star Fighter ( 2.2 mach) and in 1955 the F-105 Thunderchief (2.3 mach) are both quicker than the Avro Arrow. In 1959 the F-106 Delta Dart (2.3 mach) had it's maiden flight and served until 1988. So NATO had a few aircraft that would out perform the Arrow.

Posted: March 4, 2008, 10:11 pm
by Greg D
Johnny Canuck wrote:
Politicians. The things you see when you don't have a gun
Unless you're Dick Cheney.
http://www.toonedin.com/cheney.html
Posted: March 4, 2008, 10:13 pm
by Johnny Canuck
Mike P wrote:If you will notice in 1954 the F-104 Star Fighter ( 2.2 mach) and in 1955 the F-105 Thunderchief (2.3 mach) are both quicker than the Avro Arrow. In 1959 the F-106 Delta Dart (2.3 mach) had it's maiden flight and served until 1988. So NATO had a few aircraft that would out perform the Arrow.

Wasn't just the speed. the Arrow Mk 3 was set to top mach 3. it was the ceiling, range, stability, fly by wire etc etc etc that made it the world's best interceptor in 1958. Also that that time the F106 was barely making Mach 1, it was years of tuning before it made mach 2 the way I read it. After they cut the Arrows up, we got stuck with Voodo's, which were a dead lemon, then Starfighters until we finally got the F18.
Starfighters were known in the RCAF as "Widowmakers", they killed so many Canadian pilots,
ps good one greg
