I updated my computer to SP2 and starting using the firewall for about a week or so without any problems, and then just recently it started bumping me off.
Security Thread
Uh.....
....
...I'm using dial up.
I updated my computer to SP2 and starting using the firewall for about a week or so without any problems, and then just recently it started bumping me off.
I turned off the firewall and will see if it stops.
I updated my computer to SP2 and starting using the firewall for about a week or so without any problems, and then just recently it started bumping me off.
Gene
1961 Intregal cab SWB 223 (getting 302 & TIB)
1969 LWB 302 automatic (Donor for the '61)
2000 F150 XLT SWB (Daily Driver)
1961 Intregal cab SWB 223 (getting 302 & TIB)
1969 LWB 302 automatic (Donor for the '61)
2000 F150 XLT SWB (Daily Driver)
- banjopicker66
- Posts: 1488
- Joined: July 17, 2006, 1:59 pm
- Location: Middlesboro, KY
Gene: It isn't the firewall's fault. It is doing it's job just fine.
One function of the firewall is to reduce your visibility to other machines on the network.
Modems have a nasty habit of not disconnecting from the network properly. The user's computer may disconnect properly, but the IPS's modem will often stay open until something tells it shut off the connection you had with it. ISPs with modems only have so many pipes, or lines, so they need to keep unused lines free for others to use.
(By the way, modems designed to shut down accurately would take much much longer for you to sign on, and would be much slower.)
Instead of using a confirmed shutdown, the ISPs check the lines every few minutes with a command known as a "ping." You can use ping on your own computer. When a computer is pinged, it returns a signal, and this tells the pinger that your box is up and online.
ISPs rely on ping's return signal, or echo, from the computer connected to that modem to confirm that a modem line is still being used.
If they do not get a ping, they turn it off.
Your consistent results of 10 minutes tell me that this is the problem - your firewall is blocking ping. Although the command is ping, and is colloquially called ping, the correct term is ICMP Echo.
Unfortunately, ping is used by the bad guys to discover what computers are online, and then will attempt to attack them. They don't want to waste time and energy attacking non-existent computers.
Therefore, firewalls are configured by default to deny a response or echo to ping. This reduces your visibility to the network, but it interferes with your dial-up capability. The ISP thinks your modem line is not connected, so they shut it down.
Windows firewall has limited configurability, though. You can allow ICMP requests to go through it, and they are harmless.
WARNING: If you enable ICMP, BE SURE TO TURN ALL THIS BACK OFF if you ever go to a high speed line like DSL or cable internet.
In Control Panel, double click on Firewall. Click on the Advanced Tab, and find ICMP below. Click the Settings button to show the choices.
I would recommend you start with all of them checked. Save the settings, turn the Firewall on, and see if you can stay online.
Once you have re-established that you are not getting kicked off, go back and turn one or two off (from the bottom up) until you get kicked off again. Then, turn the last one back on.
This procedure will give you the highest possible security yet keep you online.
Of course, you could call the ISP - they might have a better answer, since they know the network best.
Good luck, and let me know how it works out.
One function of the firewall is to reduce your visibility to other machines on the network.
Modems have a nasty habit of not disconnecting from the network properly. The user's computer may disconnect properly, but the IPS's modem will often stay open until something tells it shut off the connection you had with it. ISPs with modems only have so many pipes, or lines, so they need to keep unused lines free for others to use.
(By the way, modems designed to shut down accurately would take much much longer for you to sign on, and would be much slower.)
Instead of using a confirmed shutdown, the ISPs check the lines every few minutes with a command known as a "ping." You can use ping on your own computer. When a computer is pinged, it returns a signal, and this tells the pinger that your box is up and online.
ISPs rely on ping's return signal, or echo, from the computer connected to that modem to confirm that a modem line is still being used.
If they do not get a ping, they turn it off.
Your consistent results of 10 minutes tell me that this is the problem - your firewall is blocking ping. Although the command is ping, and is colloquially called ping, the correct term is ICMP Echo.
Unfortunately, ping is used by the bad guys to discover what computers are online, and then will attempt to attack them. They don't want to waste time and energy attacking non-existent computers.
Therefore, firewalls are configured by default to deny a response or echo to ping. This reduces your visibility to the network, but it interferes with your dial-up capability. The ISP thinks your modem line is not connected, so they shut it down.
Windows firewall has limited configurability, though. You can allow ICMP requests to go through it, and they are harmless.
WARNING: If you enable ICMP, BE SURE TO TURN ALL THIS BACK OFF if you ever go to a high speed line like DSL or cable internet.
In Control Panel, double click on Firewall. Click on the Advanced Tab, and find ICMP below. Click the Settings button to show the choices.
I would recommend you start with all of them checked. Save the settings, turn the Firewall on, and see if you can stay online.
Once you have re-established that you are not getting kicked off, go back and turn one or two off (from the bottom up) until you get kicked off again. Then, turn the last one back on.
This procedure will give you the highest possible security yet keep you online.
Of course, you could call the ISP - they might have a better answer, since they know the network best.
Good luck, and let me know how it works out.
Well, Banjo, I did as suggested to no avail
. I emailed my ISP, and they just so happen to have a "fix" for XP SP2. After installing the "fix", I am no longer getting knocked offline
, but now my external speakers don't work....
Gene
1961 Intregal cab SWB 223 (getting 302 & TIB)
1969 LWB 302 automatic (Donor for the '61)
2000 F150 XLT SWB (Daily Driver)
1961 Intregal cab SWB 223 (getting 302 & TIB)
1969 LWB 302 automatic (Donor for the '61)
2000 F150 XLT SWB (Daily Driver)
