I feel like I've read every thread here and on fte and hamb in reguards to leaf springs. I'm sure I haven't as this seems to be a slightly gray topic with lots of options and opinions.
Basic info on the truck right now, it's bone stock. As far as I know anyways. Wheels are different but that's neither here nor there. I have 5 leaves up front plus the little short helper, and 4 in back plus the little helper. I don't think any have been pulled by previous owners.
I'm looking for about 4" of drop in front. I'm planning on flipping the rear axle. I think that will give me plenty. And like everyone else, cheaper is always better. But safety is worth the money as this truck will be my daily driver... Someday.
I've read about pulling leaves but it seems like that opens a geometry problem, leading to bump steer. I've looked at lowering packs but the lowest I see are 2.5" drops. Not sure if I can pull leaves from those packs but it would still open the steering problems.
Then I got to looking at monos. The drop is exactly what I want but there's so much written about them breaking and how catostrphic it would be plus the spring wrap in a hard stop... I sort of shyed away as I do hope to pull a trailer or small camper from time to time.
I also looked at reversing eyes and de-arching them because I have a press, but I've read how that shrinks the spring and again causes problems down the line with compromising the intrigrity of the metal.
I emailed Sid about dropping my axle but I don't like how close to the pavement that puts the axle.
So, has anyone actually ever heard of someone driving with monos and one snapping? Could I run one of my little flat helpers under the mono incase something did happen? I guess there's really no full proof way of dropping one of these old trucks without going IFS which I am not interested in at all. I've read several articles and interviews with Eaton springs in relation to this topic which have made me doubt if any of this can be done safely. I don't have any problem notching the frame if I need to. Thanks for all the help so far. And forgive my beating of this dead horse.
Spring question... Monos and packs
-
SteveCanup
- Posts: 1096
- Joined: November 7, 2014, 11:08 pm
- Location: Wytheville, Virginia

Re: Spring question... Monos and packs
I've run mono's for almost a year now on my '64. I did the same as you as far as researching and reading till my eyes bled. I read some posts on the HAMB about mono's breaking, but invariably the common denominator was improper installation. I do not think (Logically speaking) that mono's would be sold or used if they were that dangerous. I can't say as far as pulling a trailer though...I had thought about adding one of my original springs (a single spring leaf) to the mono to firm up the ride though. I would also be interested in anyone else's thoughts....
Steve-

Steve-

Re: Spring question... Monos and packs
That height is perfect in my opinion. That's what I'm shooting for. Just a slight tuck of the tires in the front fenders. Have you had any wheel hop during a hard stop?
- charliemccraney
- Posts: 1743
- Joined: July 9, 2008, 10:02 pm
- Location: Lawrenceville, GA
Re: Spring question... Monos and packs
This is 3" drop monos in the front and re-arched rears to level. I haven't experienced anything negative with the monos and I've had those for probably 14 years, daily driven year round in all weather conditions.
You're probably not going to be towing much unless you actually design the drop around towing so that you still have the load capacity and suspension travel. Monos or re-arching won't cut it.
If you re-arch, remove the helper springs. I didn't and after lowering the rears, the helpers are always in play. I'll probably remove the springs again to remove the helpers and have them re-arched for the same height as the ride did get more stiff after doing that.

You're probably not going to be towing much unless you actually design the drop around towing so that you still have the load capacity and suspension travel. Monos or re-arching won't cut it.
If you re-arch, remove the helper springs. I didn't and after lowering the rears, the helpers are always in play. I'll probably remove the springs again to remove the helpers and have them re-arched for the same height as the ride did get more stiff after doing that.

Lawrenceville, Ga
1961 F100 Unibody
318 Y-block (292 +.070 bore, +.170 stroke), FMS T5-Z w/Mustang 10.5" diaphragm clutch.
1961 F100 Unibody
318 Y-block (292 +.070 bore, +.170 stroke), FMS T5-Z w/Mustang 10.5" diaphragm clutch.
Re: Spring question... Monos and packs
My camper is a 60's travel-eze 10 footer so it doesn't weight much at all. I pull it with my wife's Jeep Wrangler at the moment and don't even know it's back there. I'm all single axle on campers and trailers so I don't think I'll have too much to worry about as far as pulling. It was the stopping quick with the camper I was thinking about... Just a good reason to put some electric brakes on the camper. Thanks for the tip on the helpers.
-
Hunter's 64
- Posts: 932
- Joined: January 10, 2011, 4:58 pm
- Location: High Springs Florida

Re: Spring question... Monos and packs
I have run mono for three years , don't baby truck but don"t abuse it , have launched it on drag strip a few time never had a problem, never seen a broken mono in person ?
https://www.performanceonline.com/1957- ... pring-Set/
bought mine here life time warranty
They also have a full pack front set that will drop 2-3 inches
Danny
https://www.performanceonline.com/1957- ... pring-Set/
bought mine here life time warranty
Danny
-
SteveCanup
- Posts: 1096
- Joined: November 7, 2014, 11:08 pm
- Location: Wytheville, Virginia

Re: Spring question... Monos and packs
That's where I bought mine from...Performance On Line. They have a good reputation and reasonable prices. I have found, through reading here on the internet, that people either love or hate mono-springs. I like mine. I would still like to drop my axle and get just a little more lowering. Additionally, when I installed mine (they were 4 1/2 inch drop) I did not have any bump steer. Installed them with my son's help and drove the truck... 
Re: Spring question... Monos and packs
My opinion:
"Monos", as they are generally referred to, are fine if they are properly designed. When the aftermarket first started offering mono springs for non-stock applications there were breakage problems. They tried to make them like a normal spring. They should actually be a parabolic cross section to keep from breaking and resist axle rotation. The metal can be slightly different, or not actually metal at all. Some companies condemned the mono in any non-stock application at that time and it stuck.
Part of it is because they don't differentiate between "mono" and "parabolic" leaf springs. We are actually talking about a parabolic leaf, not a mono. It's just easier to say mono. Mono is one thickness from eye to eye, parabolic gets thicker as you approach the rear end housing then thins on it's way to the rear eye. A true mono is only there as an axle locator (left/right and fore/aft) and will not resist axle rotation and requires additional "helper" type springs or torque controlling devices in the system. The thicker section of the parabolic spring doesn't need "helper" springs and resists axle rotation just fine.
I've raced mono spring cars on dirt late models off and on for 30 years, never broke a spring and I'm sure we abused them WAY more than you ever would on the street. I have seen broken mono springs but they were ancient. I've also seen failed composite parabolic springs. They generally fail from a poor installation or manufacturing error where the spring eye is attached. The only parabolic steel springs I've seen fail were in accidents or mounted incorrectly.
Adding a leaf from your stock pack will do nothing for a mono leaf system. If the eye breaks (or anywhere along the spring for that matter) another spring hooked to the mono is of no value. You have just modified the design and created a stress point where it would be more likely to break at the end of the spring you added. If the eye breaks on a stack leaf setup, you have the same problem. That does not change. The only difference is the leaf stack will partially support the broken spring, not so with any mono setup.
I have a composite mono parallel spring setup to put in the rear my '37 Ford tudor, they seem to be well accepted in the street rod world and are considered the Cadillac of rides there. It's one of the most expensive rear suspension setups you can buy for the 35-40 style frame short of IRS and lots of billet. Please don't tell the wife that part. Corvettes have used composite parabolic springs for many years with no problems. Camaros and Novas also used mono springs from the factory and there were not a great deal of failures with them. I believe those 3 cars can lead a fairly demanding life, mono style springs would not be under them if it was a huge problem.
A mono works differently than a "regular" leaf spring. They are smoother than a stack leaf because there is less friction. They don't gain rate as a stack leaf does, they remain constant thru their travel. They are not known for being great at supporting any loads other than the vehicle static weight. They generally ride better.
If I were using a mono (parabolic) style spring, I would supplement it with air shocks on the rear for those times you plan to tow. That setup has been used for many years and works pretty well.
SPark
"Monos", as they are generally referred to, are fine if they are properly designed. When the aftermarket first started offering mono springs for non-stock applications there were breakage problems. They tried to make them like a normal spring. They should actually be a parabolic cross section to keep from breaking and resist axle rotation. The metal can be slightly different, or not actually metal at all. Some companies condemned the mono in any non-stock application at that time and it stuck.
Part of it is because they don't differentiate between "mono" and "parabolic" leaf springs. We are actually talking about a parabolic leaf, not a mono. It's just easier to say mono. Mono is one thickness from eye to eye, parabolic gets thicker as you approach the rear end housing then thins on it's way to the rear eye. A true mono is only there as an axle locator (left/right and fore/aft) and will not resist axle rotation and requires additional "helper" type springs or torque controlling devices in the system. The thicker section of the parabolic spring doesn't need "helper" springs and resists axle rotation just fine.
I've raced mono spring cars on dirt late models off and on for 30 years, never broke a spring and I'm sure we abused them WAY more than you ever would on the street. I have seen broken mono springs but they were ancient. I've also seen failed composite parabolic springs. They generally fail from a poor installation or manufacturing error where the spring eye is attached. The only parabolic steel springs I've seen fail were in accidents or mounted incorrectly.
Adding a leaf from your stock pack will do nothing for a mono leaf system. If the eye breaks (or anywhere along the spring for that matter) another spring hooked to the mono is of no value. You have just modified the design and created a stress point where it would be more likely to break at the end of the spring you added. If the eye breaks on a stack leaf setup, you have the same problem. That does not change. The only difference is the leaf stack will partially support the broken spring, not so with any mono setup.
I have a composite mono parallel spring setup to put in the rear my '37 Ford tudor, they seem to be well accepted in the street rod world and are considered the Cadillac of rides there. It's one of the most expensive rear suspension setups you can buy for the 35-40 style frame short of IRS and lots of billet. Please don't tell the wife that part. Corvettes have used composite parabolic springs for many years with no problems. Camaros and Novas also used mono springs from the factory and there were not a great deal of failures with them. I believe those 3 cars can lead a fairly demanding life, mono style springs would not be under them if it was a huge problem.
A mono works differently than a "regular" leaf spring. They are smoother than a stack leaf because there is less friction. They don't gain rate as a stack leaf does, they remain constant thru their travel. They are not known for being great at supporting any loads other than the vehicle static weight. They generally ride better.
If I were using a mono (parabolic) style spring, I would supplement it with air shocks on the rear for those times you plan to tow. That setup has been used for many years and works pretty well.
SPark
1932 Ford 5 window coupe. 302/C4
1962 8V-390/C6 Unibody Short Bed Soon to be Big Window - The Lincoln that never was
2013 F150 Super Crew Eco Boost 4x4
2015 Ford Edge for the little lady, because she said so!
2007 Mustang GT, 4.6-3V/5 Speed. Only 8680 miles on the clock.
More toys, I need more toys!!!
1962 8V-390/C6 Unibody Short Bed Soon to be Big Window - The Lincoln that never was
2013 F150 Super Crew Eco Boost 4x4
2015 Ford Edge for the little lady, because she said so!
2007 Mustang GT, 4.6-3V/5 Speed. Only 8680 miles on the clock.
More toys, I need more toys!!!
Re: Spring question... Monos and packs
I just did an install of some reworked stock springs on the front of my 57
F100 which uses the same springs up front as the 58-64 Ford pickups use.
All I did to get about 2 inches of drop was to have Sid arch the main leaf the opposite direction, so it turned it in to a spring with reverse eyes. Same spring stack as before except I left out the very short bottom leaf that is about 9 inches long.
In addition I used some spring liner material between each leaf to help the leaves
slide easier. Speedway sells it in 20 foot rolls for about $15. I also bought all new
bushings and shackles to install them. Won't have it back on the road until the engine
is back in but once it is it will probably come down a couple more inches. It is a 351W
and will not be real heavy compared to an FE. Should be down just even with the top of the tire which is what I wanted. TR
F100 which uses the same springs up front as the 58-64 Ford pickups use.
All I did to get about 2 inches of drop was to have Sid arch the main leaf the opposite direction, so it turned it in to a spring with reverse eyes. Same spring stack as before except I left out the very short bottom leaf that is about 9 inches long.
In addition I used some spring liner material between each leaf to help the leaves
slide easier. Speedway sells it in 20 foot rolls for about $15. I also bought all new
bushings and shackles to install them. Won't have it back on the road until the engine
is back in but once it is it will probably come down a couple more inches. It is a 351W
and will not be real heavy compared to an FE. Should be down just even with the top of the tire which is what I wanted. TR

