Thanks for all the help gentlemen.
I did clamp the new pedal in a vice at the bottom and try pivot it back and forth and it is tight. I don't see any form of hinge in the casting. I will try cut the rubber back as uni body suggested and see if that improves it.
I don't have any form of return spring on the pedal assembly, only at the carb. So that would make a lot more sense as to why it is not returning. I will check Dennis Carpenter and see if they have any listing for the springs.
chris401 wrote:That is an older pedal than 65. The 65 had a visible hinge. Whether it makes a difference or not I do not know but up to 64 used a mechanical linkage bell crank set up with some stout springs. Stouter than the 65/66 cable set up. I replaced both of my 65 hinge pedals with a bolt up replacement suspended pedal. One spring up top by the cable end saves wear on the carburetor shaft. There are coil brackets with a spring attatchment and add brackets that use the coil bolt.
I don't see any other type of pedal that could possibly suit that pedal assembly on the Dennis Carpenter website. I would prefer the suspended type accelerator but I can't find anything here (Australia) and don't see any new available. I would even use something aftermarket (Lokar) but I am trying to avoid drilling more holes into the firewall.
If anybody has anything they want to sell and willing to ship to Australia I would be happy to cover costs.